Winged or Winging?

A relook at WingStop.

About a year ago, I wrote about WingStop (WING) when it was trading at its all-time highs. I was impressed with its asset-light model—98% of restaurants are franchisee-owned—and solid margins. Instead of writing a bullish article, I ended up writing a bearish article as I found some accounting and disclosure issues. Interestingly, at that time, WING also decided to run the infamous doorbell Ad that got dog owners all riled up. The online backlash was something to behold. WING went on to fall 50%. It did, however, recover most of it in the recent rally since April.

As a policy, I generally don’t write about companies near or around their earnings releases. It is by design so that people don’t gamble with short-term options.

In any event. WING reported earnings recently, and people loved the results. The stock shot up 25%. Once people went through the details, it got summarily sold, and it has given back all the gains and then some. The biggest red flag is the same store sales growth or degrowth. The same store sales fell 1.9% in Q2 compared to the growth of 28.7% during the same period last year.

Now, there are other issues. Let’s look at them one by one.

Cash Flow Issues

Here are the highlights of the cash flow statement for the last three quarters.

WING - Quarterly Cash Flow Highlights

If cash from operations is less than net income, one should investigate why, especially for an asset-light company like WING. Digging further into the Cash Flow Statement, one can see it is burning cash, and here are some findings:

  • If one were to take out the stock-based compensation, the picture gets worse. SBC was 6 million, 5.3 million, and 6.2 million in Q4 2024, Q1 2025, and Q2 2025, respectively.

  • The bigger issue? It has working capital issues, and the main cash burn is in the Ad spend.

So, let’s understand what is going on here. Some accounting fun for you. Do note that what WING is doing is kosher under GAAP.

WING’s main revenues are from franchisee fees and advertising fees it charges its franchisees. WING charges 6% of net sales after discounts, as franchisee fees, and 5.3% as advertising fees. Under GAAP, Ad fees get reported as revenues. All good here.

But now here is the balance sheet treatment of that. The net of what is received and what is spent on advertising shows up in the current assets as cash, and a similar amount shows up as a current liability, as it has to be eventually spent. It just can’t be held on to for perpetuity, unlike franchisee fees.

In Q2 2025, 35.5% of WING’s revenues, or 61.9 million, were from advertising fees. So, you might be wondering if WING is burning cash, how are they funding growth and paying that dividend? Good question.

In the QSR (Quick Service Restaurant) business, there is a common practice called Whole Business Securitization (WBS). WBS is basically the issuance of notes secured by a pool of income-generating assets other than financial assets, like loans or receivables, that make up substantially all the revenues of a business.

Here are the mechanics of it for any QSR.

WING did a WBS issuance of $500 million in Q4 2024. From Q2 earnings call:

… includes an $0.18 EPS impact from the additional interest associated with our $500 million securitization transaction completed in December 2024. Proceeds from this transaction were used to enhance shareholder returns and subsequently funded $370 million in share repurchases through the 2025.

Michael Skipworth, President and Chief Executive Officer, Wingstop

There you have it. See that $1.21 billion of long-term debt in the balance sheet? That is all of WBS issuances accumulated over the years. And hence, the negative retained earnings and shareholder equity.

So, where is the risk? If WING is unable to issue WBS in the future, it will have to raise capital by issuing new shares, diluting existing shareholders. For now, that scenario is plausible in case of a major slowdown in store openings or growth; however, it is a remote possibility at this time.

That brings us to what the TAM of WING is.

WING Total Addressable Market

I will be using the TAM numbers guided by WING here. Let’s have some fun. Assumptions:

  • WING will maintain its current rate of opening stores per year for ease of calculation, as it is hard to predict what they will do in the future.

  • The fee percentage charged to franchisees will remain the same.

  • Company-owned stores will remain at 2% of total stores.

I would just add that when we set our new targets, we thought about just the overall TAM for The U. S. At 6,000 plus restaurants updated from 4,000 plus as well as the AUV at the same time, moving from a $2 million target to now a $3 million target.

Alex Kalaida, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Wingstop

As with projections like this, there are assumptions, but it is close enough. Now, how much would you be willing to pay for this, taking into account what we have discussed above? I am not paying a forward P/E of 75 for this, when I also take into account the commentary from the Q2 earnings call.

Q2 Earnings Call Highlights

There were some positives and some negatives. Here are some of the highlights from the Q2 earnings call.

  • State of Consumer

I also want to acknowledge there remains a good deal of uncertainty with the consumer behaviors and implications to their spending habits. Through our regular consumer research, we hear concerns about elevated prices, future job prospects and general anxiety about the future.

Michael Skipworth, President and Chief Executive Officer, Wingstop
  • Wingstop Smart Kitchen

I’m excited to say that today, the Wingstop Smart Kitchen is live in 1,000 restaurants across The U. S, and we are on track for a full system implementation by year end. Although still early, the results from our initial markets are encouraging. Just four weeks into their implementation, we’re measuring 40% reductions in average ticket times with restaurants ramping faster towards our steady state operating model.

We are also seeing improvements in all dayparts, including our lunch and late night dayparts, which we believe is an untapped opportunity for us.

With Wingstop Smart Kitchen, we are unlocking delivery times under thirty minutes on the third party delivery marketplaces, and we are now in the consideration set for those guests. For our restaurants in the Dallas Fort Worth market, year over year sales growth in the delivery channel is outpacing The US average growth rate by mid single digits.

Michael Skipworth, President and Chief Executive Officer, Wingstop
  • Digital Business

But we think it’s going to be something pretty unique in the industry and we’re a bit advantaged with what we have in our digital business that’s over 70% strong.

Michael Skipworth, President and Chief Executive Officer, Wingstop
  • Loyalty Program

With the launch of My Wingstop, coupled with our rich database of digital guest insights, we are uniquely positioned to to build and subsequently launch a differentiated loyalty program designed to strengthen guest engagement by encouraging repeat visits and deepening the emotional connection guests have with our brand.

Michael Skipworth, President and Chief Executive Officer, Wingstop

Duolingo

After DUOL’s CEO insulted teachers in May, I have not been able to let go of this. One of the risks I highlighted in my article in May, before all of that unfolded, was the edgy marketing of DUOL. Specifically, I said with one misstep, these guys will be in trouble. Here is what the CEO said in the recent earnings call.

The reason we came towards the lower end was because I said some stuff about AI, and this was — I didn't give enough context. And because of that, we got, particularly in our social media, we got some backlash on it.

Luis von Ahn, CEO, Duolingo

The market couldn’t care less. The stock was trading up 35% on Thursday. While I was pontificating on X, explaining why I maintained my negative views, OpenAI was doing its GPT-5 demo. As part of the demo, OpenAI built a French learning app in under three minutes. The carnage began. DUOL lost more than half of its gains to end the day up 14%. On Friday, it lost 6% more, giving up most of the earnings spike.

As I have said, not everything is in the numbers and accounting. In any event, there is a lot of other stuff going on in the tariffs and geopolitical space. As more clarity is emerging, I am able to game theory out “stuff” now.

Until next time. Have fun!!!